| 2009 | Yale |
| 2008 | Yale |
| 2007 | no race |
| 2006 | Yale |
| 2005 | Cornell |
| 2004 | Cornell |
Yale v. Cornell April 18, 2009 Derby, CT
| VARSITY | 2nd VARSITY | 1st FRESHMAN | ||||||
| Yale | 5:41.2 | Yale | 5:51.8 | Cornell | 5:51.8 | |||
| Cornell | 5:42.7 | Cornell | 5:54.9 | Yale | 5:54.3 | |||
| 3rd VARSITY | 2nd FRESHMAN | |||||||
| Yale | 5:54.2 | Cornell | 6:11.8 | |||||
| Cornell | 5:57.9 | Yale | 6:37.9 | |||||