Captains 1927 - 2016
| 2016 | Austin M. Velte |
| 2015 | Matthew H. Cecil |
| 2014 | Matthew C. O’Donoghue |
| 2013 | William D. Ferraro |
| 2012 | A. David Walker |
| 2011 | Andrew F. Hakanson |
| 2010 | Brendan M. McCook |
| 2009 | Daniel R. C. Ensslen |
| 2008 | Peter J. Reiser |
| 2007 | Brendan J. Stallard |
| 2006 | Joseph J. Fallon |
| 2005 | Stephen Alexander Ramsay |
| 2004 | Tamas B. Toro |
| 2003 | Benjamin D. Hamilton |
| 2002 | Ian A. Malloch |
| 2001 | Andrew J. Morley |
|
2000 |
Thaddeus D. Pollock |
|
1999 |
Guillem Gonzalez-Lomas |
|
1998 |
Steven J. Purdy |
|
1997 |
Eric M. T. Den Besten |
|
1996 |
Jeremy Woodlee |
|
1995 |
Justin P. Wheeler |
|
1994 |
Benjamin Ryan |
|
1993 |
Carl K. Gjertson |
|
1992 |
J.A. Alex Seldomridge III |
|
1991 |
Robb L. Romp |
|
1990 |
Cole C. Grissom |
|
1989 |
Patrick S. Perry |
|
1988 |
Timothy C. Howle |
|
1987 |
Mark D.R. Chutkow |
|
1986 |
James H.E. Fosburgh |
|
1985 |
James S. Herman Jr. |
|
1984 |
James A. Faust Jr. |
|
1983 |
Charles F. McGlashan IV |
|
1982 |
Steven J. Gavin |
|
1981 |
S. Kenneth Kannapan |
|
1980 |
John Reichenbach |
|
1979 |
Douglas A. Bartlett |
|
1978 |
David B. Cooper Jr. |
|
1977 |
Donald G. Kilpatrick |
|
1976 |
Mark H. Sheppard |
|
1975 |
Gail A. Ferris |
|
1974 |
Karl D. Lange |
|
1973 |
David S. Thomas |
|
1972 |
Michael J. Yaremchuk |
|
1971 |
David H. Vogel |
|
1970 |
Alan B. Minier |
|
1969 |
Kenneth R. Mischner |
|
1968 |
Christopher L. Tilghman |
|
1967 |
James G. Avery II |
|
1966 |
William H. Rodgers III |
|
1965 |
Michael R. Harrison |
|
1964 |
Richard F. Wood |
|
1963 |
David E. Hamilton |
|
1962 |
Hervey P. Clark |
|
1961 |
E. Nicholas F. Gardiner |
|
1960 |
Henry H. Bladgen |
|
1959 |
Jonathan Edelstein |
|
1958 |
John G. Crossman |
|
1957 |
Stephen V. Flagg |
|
1956 |
John R. Fell Jr. |
|
1955 |
A. Page Browne |
|
1954 |
William G.T. Shedd Jr. |
|
1954 |
Patrick F. Crossman |
|
1953 |
Everett A. Gilcreast |
|
1952 |
Arthur Moseley, Jr. |
|
1951 |
Wallace E. Sarran Jr. |
| 1950 | Wallace E. Sarran Jr. |
|
1949 |
David W. Fisher |
|
1948 |
- |
| 1947 | Joseph R. Brown, Jr. |
| 1943 - 1946 | - |
|
1942 |
William N. Fessenden |
|
1941 |
William D. Fisher |
|
1940 |
Charles D. Dickey Jr. |
|
1939 |
Norman C. Cross |
|
1938 |
Roger C. Newberry |
|
1937 |
Joseph H. Bascom |
|
1936 |
Horace Havermeyer Jr. |
|
1935 |
Henry H. Babcock |
|
1934 |
Eads Johnson Jr. |
|
1933 |
Thomas P. Blagden |
|
1932 |
J. Geer Wilcox |
|
1931 |
William M. Bowden |
|
1930 |
DeWitt Dominick |
|
1929 |
William P. Jenkins |
|
1928 |
William P. Jenkins |
|
1927 |
James W. Hinckley III |